| Bairdstown | 1881 |
| Bloomdale | 1887 |
| Bradner | 1889 |
| Custar (formerly Lewisburg) | 1881 |
| Cygnet | 1889 |
| Grand Rapids (formerly Gilead) | 1885 |
| Haskins | 1869 |
| Hoytville | 1886 |
| Jerry City (first Stulltown, then Shiloh) | 1875 |
| Luckey | 1940 |
| Millbury | 1874 |
| Milton Center | 1869 |
| North Baltimore | 1876 |
| Pemberville | 1876 |
| Portage (first called Portageville) | 1857 |
| Risingsun (St. Elms, then Coontown) | 1879 |
| Tontogany | 1874 |
| Walbridge | 1912 |
| Wayne (Freeport, then Prairie Depot) | 1836 |
| West Millgrove | 1874 |
| Weston (once known as Taylor Town) | 1873 |